A Costly Subpoena: NAR’s Harassment Records Fight
NAR subpoenaed harassment-victim records from a rival group in a pocket listing lawsuit. Here’s what it means for real estate agents.
Let me tell you about a moment that should stop you mid-scroll. A lawsuit about private listings just reached for the private conversations of people who said they were harassed. And the party doing the reaching was the National Association of Realtors, the organization many of you pay dues to every year.
I want to walk through this with you carefully, because it is easy to get spun, and you deserve the facts before the opinions.
Start with the case.
Mauricio Umansky’s private listing network, thePLS.com, has been fighting NAR over the Clear Cooperation Policy since 2020. CCP is the rule that says once you publicly market a listing, you have one business day to get it into the MLS. The plaintiffs say that rule was designed to box out networks that compete with the MLS. They argue “the surge in consumer demand for pocket listings… was a competitive threat to the viability of the NAR-affiliated MLS system” (thePLS.com amended complaint, July 2025). NAR says the policy is “lawful, justified, procompetitive, pro-consumer” and that nobody was actually injured (NAR response filing, September 2025). thePLS.com refiled the suit in July 2025 (Inman, June 22, 2026; HousingWire, June 23, 2026).
Honest people land in different places on CCP. I have said so in this space before. That debate is fair game.
Here is where it stops being ordinary. On May 19, NAR sent a subpoena to the American Real Estate Association, the rival group co-founded by Umansky and Compass agent Jason Haber, asking for documents by June 18 (NAR subpoena, May 19, 2026). Some of it was normal antitrust discovery. Communications among ARA, thePLS.com, and its Spanish-language counterpart. But it also demanded every record connected to the NAR Accountability Project, going all the way back to January 1, 2017.
Friends, that project is not a listing network. Haber started it in 2023, after sexual misconduct allegations against then-NAR President Kenny Parcell, who resigned that August. It gave people inside the organization a place to report harassment.
Haber said no. “The NAR Accountability Project shut down before ARA even existed,” he wrote on Instagram. “I’ll leave it to you to ask what its files have to do with a case about private listings.” Those records, he said, “include highly sensitive conversations with victims who came forward about harassment inside NAR,” and ARA “is objecting in the strongest possible terms.” He added, “We will fight this. And we will protect the people who deserve to be protected” (Jason Haber, Instagram, June 22, 2026).
Powerfact: When you want to understand a fight, do not listen to the press releases. Look at what each side reaches for when the pressure is on.
Now let me be fair, because that is how we do things here. NAR built something genuinely good. The cooperative MLS system that CCP defends is the reason a buyer in almost any town in America can see nearly every home for sale through nearly any agent. Most of the world does not have that. NAR helped create it, and that deserves real respect. I am not interested in piling on an organization just because it is fashionable to do so.
But respect and accountability live together. A subpoena is not weather that happens to you. It is a decision someone makes. And the decision to demand years of harassment-victim communications, in a case about a listing rule, is going to feel to a lot of members like a warning shot rather than a search for evidence. A judge may narrow it next month. The members already saw what the first version wanted.
Powerfact: An institution can win in court and still lose its people. Trust does not come back with a favorable ruling.
So here is your homework, and I mean it as a coach, not a scold.
Read it yourself. The subpoena is public. Haber’s statement is public. Do not let the first email in your inbox tell you what to think. You are smarter than the spin.
Protect your own business. None of this changes the rulebook. CCP is still in force. Market a listing publicly and the clock starts. Do not let a leadership story become an excuse for a compliance mistake that costs you money.
Lead your sellers. Right now, homeowners are hearing scary fragments about lawsuits, private networks, and portals banning listings. Be the steady one. Explain the tradeoffs with facts and let them decide. That steadiness is exactly what a POWER AGENT® brings to the table, and it is worth more than any portal.
The lawsuit will end the way these things end, in a document most of us never open. What will stick is the memory of how the institution acted when it had a choice. NAR can still narrow this request and show the restraint it asks members to trust it with. I hope it does. Because the agents watching right now are not asking who wins. They are asking a quieter, harder question. Can I trust the people who say they represent me? Answer that one well, and everything else gets easier.
Get the latest real estate training tips delivered to your inbox!
Stay Ahead of What’s Coming Next
The private listings battle is moving fast and the agents and brokers who stay informed will be the ones who are prepared when the next chapter hits their market. For everything you need to know about the MRED-Compass-Zillow dispute, MLS governance, and the private listings debate as it unfolds, bookmark PrivateListingsDebate.com — your go-to source for real-time updates, talking points, and the analysis that keeps you one step ahead at the kitchen table.
For Agents: The industry is shifting fast and the agents who thrive are the ones who show up informed. Subscribe to our free weekly newsletter for hot-topic industry news, skill-building training, and the insights you need to serve your clients with confidence. Hit the Subscribe button above to get started.
For Brokers and Team Leaders: The decisions you make in the next few weeks will shape how your brokerage navigates the rest of 2026. The Leadership Lens Newsletter delivers weekly leadership strategy, talking points for your sales meetings, and the industry intelligence you need to lead with conviction. Sign up here — it’s free.